A Fine Line Between Stupid and Clever

Sep 19, 2026 by Daniel de Visé
This Is Spinal Tap” feels like the ultimate cult film: powerfully appealing to a select group of fans, baffling to everyone else. Studio executives found Rob Reiner’s 1984 “mockumentary” utterly unfunny. Test screenings in Dallas and Seattle were disastrous. Many theatergoers thought it was a serious documentary about a real band. Either you got the joke or you didn’t.

In fact, the jokes in “This Is Spinal Tap” weren’t really jokes. The humor was deadpan, and I suppose it was subtle, although I can’t imagine not laughing at it. Perhaps you needed some working knowledge of Yoko and the Beatles to find something funny in the overreaching band girlfriend who mispronounces “Dolby.” Maybe only Yardbirds fans got the merciless British Invasion parody “Gimme Some Money” and spotted the Jeff Beck pageboy mop atop Nigel Tufnel’s head. And maybe you had to be in a band yourself to grasp the ignominy of taking second billing to a puppet show on an amusement-park stage.

But we music heads love “This Is Spinal Tap.” We’ve spent decades wondering at the specific source of every shot in the film. Was the song “Stonehenge” a sendup of Led Zeppelin at its most pompous and Tolkienesque? Which real-life band lost the most drummers to bizarre gardening accidents? Did any actual bass player ever get trapped onstage inside a giant plastic pod?

Now, at last, we have answers.